Schlueter Blog Tech

When your water heater stops working, several things can happen depending on the cause of the failure. Here’s what you might experience and how to troubleshoot.

Common Signs of Water Heater Stopping

  • No Hot Water – This is the best sign to show that your water heater isn’t working
  • Lukewarm Water – Your water heater isn’t working to its full potential
  • Weird Noises – Popping, rumbling, or hissing is a sure sign of sediment buildup or a failed heating element
  • Leaking Water – A puddle or leak around the heater means there’s a leak either in the tank or pipes
  • Brownish Water or Smelly Water – Rusty or smelly water could mean corrosion in the tank
  • Water Temperature Changes – Inconsistent water heating may indicate that a faulty thermostat or heating element
  • Pilot Light Out – A pilot light that won’t stay lit can prevent the heater from functioning

Causes & Solutions

  • Power Issues – Check that your circuit breaker has tripped for electric water heaters and reset it. For Gas Water Heaters, Ensure the gas supply is turned on and the pilot light is lit.
  • Thermostat Malfunction – Adjust the temperature setting on the thermostat; if it’s not working, the thermostat may need to be replaced
  • Heating Element Failure (Electric) – The heating elements in electric water heaters can burn out and need replacing
  • Sediment Buildup – When your water heater makes popping, hissing noises or heats insufficiently, flushing out the tank might help remove the sediment.
  • Leaks – Check loose connections or cracks if water leaks from the tank. If the tank itself is leaking, it usually means replacement is necessary
  • Pressure Relief Valve Issues – If the pressure relief valve is faulty or leaking, it may need replacement

What to do Next

For minor issues, try resetting the circuit breaker, relighting the pilot light, or adjusting the thermostat.

Remember that minor issues usually indicate that a significant problem is coming or already here. It might be time to replace your water heater. A trusted plumber like Schlueter Plumbing can pinpoint the real issue and explain what’s happening. We will fix the water heater issues, and it is 100% guaranteed.

For persistent problems, it may be that your water heater is out of date; if it’s 8-12 years old, it needs replacing.

Contact Schlueter Plumbing, and we will handle the water heater replacement or upgrade for you.

For leaks or major failures, please shut off the water supply and the power source and call Schlueter immediately. We are your emergency plumber who can help anytime.

Always remember, when dealing with appliances like water heaters, it’s best to call the professionals to assess what’s happening. Call or text Schlueter Plumbers at their main line at 513-771-7588 or click here to schedule an appointment.